CNC Tapping: Holders, Attachments, Rigid, + Feeds & Speeds [Quick Info]

Is Manual Machining Faster than CNC for Simple Parts?

 

CNC Tapping: Holders, Attachments, Rigid, + Feeds & Speeds [Quick Info]

Quick info on CNC Tapping including tap holders, tap collets, tapping attachments, rigid tapping, feeds & speeds, and more.

Cutting Threads: Tapping, Single Point Threading, and Thread Milling

There are a variety of ways to make threads on CNC Machines, namely by tapping, single point threading, and by thread milling. Each one has pros and cons and is well suited to particular tasks. Single Point Threading is done on lathes, rather than mills, and involves a cutter whose shape is the thread form. That cutter is synchronized to the rotation of the part so it perfectly tracks the helix that is a thread. Successive passes cut deeper and deeper. Thread Milling is the equivalent for a milling machine. Instead of spinning the part, a thread mill is spun. It’s teeth are shaped similarly to the thread form of the thread to be cut. The cutter describes a helix that is the same as the helix of the thread itself and so the thread is cut. You can see the common theme in both cases is synchronized motion in 2 dimensions to create a helix.

Tapping is no different in that motion needs to be synchronized, but the synchronization does not have to come from the machine. You’ve no doubt used a wood screw that cut its own threads in the wood as you turned it. A tap does the same thing. It is important that the downward motion of the tap into the workpiece proceed fast enough relative to the rotation of the spindle to match the threads. Otherwise, the tap will be stretched if the downward motion is too slow and the threads outrun the tap or compressed if the downward motion is so fast that the tap is being pushed down faster than the threads allow. Either one is bad. Taps are simpler in many ways than the other two types since the tap regulates the motion and the machine just has to be close to where the tap thinks it should be.

Let’s look at the pros and cons on mills and lathes. First, we’ll consider tapping versus thread milling for mills:

– Tapping can be quite a bit faster than thread milling, particular on a machine set up for rigid tapping.

– Tapping can usually thread deeper holes, particularly in harder materials such as steel.

– A different sized tap is required for each type of thread, whereas a thread mill can work for multiple sizes. You’ll run out of spots in your tool changer faster with tapping than thread milling on a job that has a lot of different thread sizes.

– Thread milling can create both internal and external threads, whereas taps are only good for internal threads.

– A tap needs a tapered tip, so there is a limit to how close the threads can be to the bottom of blind hole. That limit means thread mills can thread closer to the bottom of the hole.

– Not only can a thread mill cut more than one thread size, but they can also adjust the exact tolerance of the thread. A tap cuts on thread, period. Custom threads are possible, whereas with a tap, you’d have to order a custom made tap which would be quite expensive.

– Thread mills can be used in slightly harder materials than taps. The tapping limit is about 50 Rc and for thread milling about 60Rc.

– Thread mills typically require much higher speed spindles than taps.

– Thread mills can do more than thread. For example, they may also be used to chamfer the hole.

– Taps can require more spindle power than thread mills.

– A tap is only good for one thread direction–right hand or left hand threads, not both. A thread mill can be used for either.

Bottom Line: Taps are chosen for speed and simplicity, whereas thread mills are chosen for flexibility.

What about lathes?

The pros and cons are almost the same, with single point threading standing in for thread milling.

Types of Taps

Left to right: Spiral flute tap, thread forming plug tap, thread forming bottoming tap…

A great variety of taps are available with varying advantages and disadvantages.  See our Complete Guide to Types of Thread Taps to learn all about them:

[ Complete Guide to Types of Thread Taps ]

CNC Tapping Feeds and Speeds

Tapping Feeds and Speeds may be based on manufacturer’s recommendations for type of tap (Form versus Cut Taps use differing feeds and speeds since they work so differently), tap material (you can get both HSS and Carbide Taps), and the material being tapped.

We offer a free online Tap Speed and Feed Calculator, but our G-Wizard Calculator software will do a lot better job for you. Here is a typical Feeds and Speeds scenario for a Cutting Tap all set up in GW Calculator:

Calculating Tapping Feeds and Speeds with G-Wizard Calculator….

Setting up a Tapping Feeds and Speeds Calculation is easy:

1. Select your machine profile and material at top left.

2. Choose either a Carbide or HSS Tap from the Tool Menu. Or, if you have one in a pre-defined Tool Crib, select the Crib below and then pick it off the Tool menu.

3. Enter the thread Major Diameter. Enter the Thread Pitch. TPI will be displayed to the right of the Pitch. We’re set up for a 1/4-20 tap in the screen shot.  For a complete set of thread dimensions, try our G-Wizard Thread Calculator.

4. If you’re using a Form Tap, check the Form Tap box just to the right of the Stickout box.

Any further tweaks are optional, but the Tortoise-Hare Slider is one that makes it easy to go from Aggressive to Conservative if you’re concerned that the tap is delicate or the material is touch. Feeds and Speeds will read out as you make each change to the settings.

Tapping Holders & Tap Collets

Some sort of holder is essential for tapping.  Here are the most common types:

ER Tap Collets

You can use regular ER collets and an ER Collet chuck as your tapping holder, but there are special ER Tap Collets that are designed to lock the square portion of the tap shank so the tap can’t spin in the collet.  For example, Techniks makes ER Tap Collets:

These Tap Collets have a square pocket in the bottom of the collet that locks the tap from spinning.

ANSI Tap Collets (aka “Bilz” Tap Holders)

These kind are nice because of their quick release feature:

ANSI Tap Collet by Teckniks

They’re also called “Bilz” Tap Holders after the company that invented them.

Tapping Attachments & Heads

Broken taps are a pain!

Having selected a tap to fit your needs, and having some idea of how to hold it in your spindle, you’re ready to stick it in the machine and go tapping, right? Not so fast, unless your machine supports rigid tapping, you’ll also need a tapping head of some kind.

What is Rigid Tapping?

Rigid Tapping is the capability for a machine to precisely synchronize the feedrate to the spindle speed so the tap is advanced as the threads require without need of any special attachment.

Rigid tapping is highly prized for this reason and because it is generally faster than using a tapping head of any kind. To do rigid tapping requires an encoder on your spindle plus a controller smart enough to use the data from the encoder to precisely synchronize the feedrate based on the requirements of the thread being tapped.

While Rigid Tapping is extremely popular, it’s not necessarily the be all and end all of CNC Tapping.  Be sure to check out our article on the Advantages and Pitfalls of Rigid Tapping to learn more.  In particular, you’ll learn why a floating tap holder may be a good idea even if you’re rigid tapping.

Many CNC machines, especially older and less expensive machines, are not set up for rigid tapping. For those machines, some form of tapping head must be used. The tapping head has some play along its axis and is spring-loaded so if the feedrate isn’t precise, it just lets the thread itself govern the difference and the spring takes up any slack. It turns out that even when rigid tapping, it may pay off in terms of longer tap life to use a floating holder of some kind. Check out our blog post on this issue for details.

Tension Compression or Floating Tap Holders & Heads

If your machine is not equipped for Rigid Tapping, the next possibility is a floating tap holder, also called a “tension compression tap holder.”

Here is a typical Tension/Compression Holder:

tension compression floating tap holder head

A typical Tension-Compression Tap Holder, this one by Tormach

These devices have a collet arrangement of some kind to hold the tap, and the collet chuck is capable of sliding up and down along the axis for a short distance. A spring keeps it positioned near the center of its travel. Dave DeCaussin’s video on how he makes his own tension compression holders gives great insight into how they work:

Dave DeCaussin shows how he makes Tension Compression Tapping Heads…

The ability to float means that as long as the relationship between spindle rpms and feedrate is pretty close to the needs of the thread, all will be well and the tap will get the job done.

Auto-Reversing Tapping Heads

The next step up in complexity is to use a Tapping Heads. These heads are available from companies like Tapmatic, Procunier, and others. They include far more sophisticated mechanisms than Floating Tap Holders. Namely, they have an auto-reverse gearbox and a slip clutch. What that means is that as soon as the spindle starts to retract, the tapping head reverses direction automatically. Frequently the reversing gears operate at higher speed since it is possible to retract more quickly than one can cut threads. The slip clutch can be set to a torque rating based on tap size so you’re less likely to break a tap through the application of too much torque.

Here is a typical Auto-Reversing Tapping Head:

auto-reversing tapping head

Tapping Head from Tapmatic

Tapping Heads incorporate friction slip clutches, axial free play, and a reversing feature that automatically reverses the spin direction when the feed direction reverses. They were originally created to make tapping easy for drill presses and manual milling machines. They can be used on CNC machines, but they’re not nearly as common as Rigid Tapping or Tension/Compression Holders.

Here is a great video from Tormach on the use of a Procunier Tapping Head in their CNC Mill:

Demonstration by Tormach of Procunier Tapping Head…

Pros and Cons

As with anything, there are a number of Pros and Cons with each method:

– Rigid Tapping is the fastest method, followed by a Tapping Head which is typically about 25% faster than a Tension Compression Holder. The reason is the Tapping Head can reverse much more quickly and can also typically be programmed to tap more quickly and retract more quickly as less safety margin is needed. There is an exception to this rule which is that a Tapping Head can be faster for very small taps depending on the acceleration/deceleration and rpm capabilities of your machine’s spindle.

– For machines that don’t do Rigid Tapping (which in itself is often an expensive option), Tension Compression Tap Holders are the cheapest answer for tapping. A Tapping Head is much more expensive.

– In most cases, a Tapping Head cannot be used with an Automatic Tool Changer. It needs a stop to keep it from rotating and often they’re too bulky to fit into an ATC. There are exceptions, but obvious the loss of automatic tool change capability can be a real disadvantage for a Tapping Head.

– Through Spindle Coolant can be very helpful as taps like to be lubricated. It’s often difficult to arrange for TSC with Tapping Heads and Tension Compression Holders.

– If the spring in a Tension Compression Holder breaks or the mechanism in a Tapping Head fails, you’re going to have real problems. Rigid Tapping is much more reliable for that reason.

– Tool Holders for Rigid Tapping are much less expensive usually than Tension Compression Holders or Tapping Heads. They are also often more compact, which can be useful when clearances or travels are tight.

Summary: Be very happy if your machine has Rigid Tapping. If it doesn’t you’re going to have to evaluate the tradeoffs of pure tapping speed for a given tap (Tapping Head) versus tool changer capability and cheaper holders (Tension Compression Holder).

Tapping Fluid

As mentioned, taps really like some lubrication to prolong their life. For many cases, the machine’s flood coolant suffices. But for more difficult jobs, a dedicated tapping fluid may be needed. Most everyone has heard of Tap Magic as one possibility, but the machinists in places like Practical Machinist swear that Castrol’s Moly-Dee is the true magical stuff for making taps work better. A 16oz supply goes a long way and a gallon almost seems to last forever. Do yourself a favor and get some of this magic elixir for tap longevity!

Most CNC’ers hate the idea of using Tapping Fluid. They don’t want to have to stand in the door brushing it on the tap. I can’t blame them, it’s boring and moderately dangerous. But there is another way. Get one of those “No-Tip” containers for tapping fluid. Put it on the table and program the CNC to dip the tap into the container between holes.

Start With the Right Hole!

What if I told you starting with the right hole was going to make more difference than almost anything else for your tapping, at least in terms of not breaking taps?

Even more interesting, what if I told you that the hole size in readily available tap and drill charts and on your tap’s packaging is probably the wrong choice once you know how to choose the hole size more intelligently?

We’ve written an entire article about tap drill size and it is worth your time to stop right here and go check it out.

Just to make sure you know what’s at stake, here’s the kicker:

Imagine the fully formed internal thread.  Each thread rises from valley to peak.  Now suppose you ran a twist drill down the hole and shaved off some of the peaks.  They’re pretty delicate anyway and will wear off quickly.  In fact, they contribute surprisingly little strength.  A 100% thread is only 5% stronger than 75% thread.  But here is the real kicker:

That 100% thread requires 3 times the power to tap!

3 times the power to tap generally means 3 times as likely to break a tap. At least that’s how Mr Murphy runs things in my shop.

GCode for Tapping

That pretty well covers Tapping, but leaves open the question of how to program the various tapping alternatives on a CNC. That’s a subject better left to our GCode Tutorial, so we’ll provide a detailed article over there to help you out with it.

Next Article: Slitting Saw Feeds and Speeds & Techniques

 

 

CNC Tapping: Holders, Attachments, Rigid, + Feeds & Speeds [Quick Info]
5 (100%) 1 vote