|
More
Recent Blog Entries...
July Through September CNC Blog Archive
9/28/06
Eliminating Backlash
For the benefit of those trying
to eliminate backlash, I spent the evening writing a couple of Cookbook
recipes that gather up as many ideas and thoughts as I could, based
on my travels through the Internet.
Eliminating
Backlash Part 1: The Basics. This is a basic treatise on ballscrews
and using angular contact bearings to mount them.
Eliminating
Backlash Part 2: Refinements. This assumes you've got your
ballscrews installed and you are still not happy, which is the case here.
There are some things I've run across that have not been mentioned often,
and I hope that putting it all together in one place will be helpful as
well.
9/24/06
Gecko Drive Mounting Bracket for CNC Lathe
After looking
over what others had done to mount their Gecko drives, I decided to
use some heatsink extrusion to make a bracket. I mounted the fuses in
the bracket right next to the appropriate drive:


I need to put
a label next to each drive so I can tell which axis is which. One more
thing done building the driver electronics
enclosure. The next step is to build a sub-chassis that will carry
the relays and other auxilliary components needed to control the spindle
and coolant.
Tapping Arms
I had occassion to drill and
tap some holes on my CNC Lathe project
(making a heatsink/mounting bracket for the Gecko Drives), and got to
thinking about Tapping Arms:

Flexarm Tapping
Arm...


These gadgets
are designed for production shops so that someone can rapidly tap a whole
bunch of holes. They look extremely handy and easy to use, and I've heard
lots of good about them on Practical Machinist (the owner of the site
seems
to have invented the darned things!). I sure could have used one for
my project! The subject comes up on Practical Machinist usually because
someone can't do rigid tapping in their CNC. Someone else usually suggests
they buy a tapping arm rather than a new CNC. This is relevant to amateurs
because Mach 3 doesn't support rigid tapping at the moment. The only bad
news is that they seem to cost $1200 to $5000 and up. Wow!
The interesting
question is how hard would it be to make one of these gizmos? The arm
itself is very simple. In a pinch, you could probably use a monitor arm
designed for a PC, assuming you were willing to accept a little lower
capacity and strength. What about the motor? I'm thinking an import butterfly
impact wrench or something similar is about perfect. Failing that, it
seems like you could adapt a Tapmatic or other tapping head to an air
or electric motor. Whatever motor is used needs to be reversible. What
I like about these things is they look like they would make tapping a
snap and they also stay out of the way. I could imagine attaching one
to the corner of the welding table and forgetting about it. Seems like
a perfect small workshop project!
Nice Rail Design for Plasma and Router
Tables

Skate-O-Rail!

All in all, looks
like a pretty decent railing system that would be easy to build.
9/22/06
Big Doings for the Site
After much head scratching
and soul searching, I've decided to decouple the look and feel of the
machine tool pages from the rest of TheWarfields.com. You have in your
hands the result of that effort. I'm hoping the navigation makes a little
more sense, the design is a little cleaner and crisper, but most of all,
that it just makes these pages more useful and more fun. Before launching
into this move, I spend quite a lot of time poking around the Internet
to see what I liked in various sites. I'm pretty happy with the overall
result.
9/19/06
Cool
5-axis Milling Head

DS
Technologie Z3 5-Axis Head...
It uses 3 sets
of linear rails in a triangular configuration with pivots. I wonder if
Mach 3 can handle the kinematic formulas for this kind of thing? Woo Hoo!
I like it because
it looks easier to build than the typical 2-rotary-axis machines.
9/17/06
Finished
the DC Power Supply for my CNC Lathe
project this weekend!

Options
for entry level CNC
I was recently perusing a thread
on Practical Machinist, and as I watched the feathers fly, what first
seemed like total disagreement and conflicting evidence gradually coalesced
into a stratified view of the options. It is basically a trade off between
performance versus dollars and personal skill. You can offset dollars
with a lot of personal skill to modify a machine and improve its performance,
or you can use dollars to buy a higher performance machine. The pecking
order for dollars/skill looks like this:
|
Most Skill
/ Least Dollars |
- Do your own conversion. This is the path I am following
on my CNC Lathe, albeit slowly.
One thread contributor, Dirt Rider, proved the lowest end can
succeed brilliantly if you have the right skills. He did this
even starting with a round column mill, thought to be the lowliest
of lows by many. I'm not sure the Haas guys can show nicer parts,
but they probably make more of them faster. With that said, this
would clearly require a lot of time and personal skill to duplicate.

Simple round column mill with flood coolant
enclosure...

Gives spectacular results!
|
|
- Modify or retrofit a machine. This is
very close in cost to "buy a kit" and also in the demands it places
on your skills. One of the best examples here is our very own "Anvil".
Track down his threads about his Tree 325. It's an older CNC knee
mill, and he produces spectacular results with it: www.anvilbikes.com.
There is a lot to be said for finding an older CNC mill whose controller
is dead, and refitting it with a PC/Mach 3 controller. If you get
lucky, the spindle, ways, ballscrews, motors, and power supply will
all be good and you wind up with a fantastic mill for a good price.
I've been watching the Tree 325 market myself, and it looks to be
about a $3500 machine. One could also easily refit a Tormach with
servos. Go find the right NEMA form factor servos, replace the stepper
Geckos (2xx series) with servo Geckos (3xx series), and you are
done. I would also upgrade from Mach 2 to Mach 3. This would be
a trivial upgrade and should allow you to dial in much faster performance.
I am surprised nobody has tried it yet. |
- Buy a kit. Industrial Hobbies is probably
the best example, and I bought their kit to eventually install on
my IH Mill (gotta finish the lathe
first!). A couple of things to note. They just revised their basic
mill to use ground ways--no more lapping, which one thread fellow
was on about. It also uses servos, which I
agree are higher performance. There are some movies up no on
their site so you can see it in action. Take a look at "making a
small part". Compare that to the videos on the Tormach site and
you can see how much slower the Tormach is. Again, it may not matter
to your application, don't get overly hung up on it, but it is a
great demo of the servo vs stepper performance gap. |
|
- Buy a real VMC used, but working: Cheaper
than new, make sure you know how to evaluate one. |
|
- Buy a new low end VMC: This is the Rolls
Royce route, but if you have an immediate business opportunity making
parts in any volume, it may be your best option to getting your
business successful as quickly as possible. |
|
Least Skill
/ Most Dollars |
9/15/06
Precision
Linear Rail Support With Moglice for Gantry Machines
I've been doing a lot of pondering
lately after reading an MIT PhD MechE's thesis on designing and building
CNC machines. To find your own copy of this 200+ page tome, Google for
"Principles of Rapid Machine Design." The fellow that wrote
it is a Professor Bamberg, who injected a number of thought provoking
ideas via his thesis into my consciousness as far as how to build machines
that will be very accurate yet relatively inexpensive and straightforward
to create for an advanced Home Shop Machinist. Once the juices got flowing,
it resulted in the 5-Axis T&C grinder doodle below. I wanted to set
down here another application, which I've been discussing with JerryFlyGuy
and others over on the CNCZone, and that is how to mount linear rails
on a fabricated (likely welded) substructure with precision.
The salient idea is to make
the precision structure on which the rails are mounted separate from the
fabricated (often welded, but could be bolted together) structure needed
for support and rigidity. The magic interface between the two is a special
epoxy used by machine builders called Moglice.
Note that this method is also useful when attaching two parts of a machine
together that require a precise orientation to one another, for instance,
when getting a column square with the base of a mill, or perhaps even
getting headstock of a lathe square with the bed.
In practice, one fabricates
both pieces separately, and then bolts them together leaving the bolts
loose enough so there is an approximately 1mm gap between the two. A system
of setscrews (or leveling screws if you prefer) is used to achieve the
precise alignment desired, and then Moglice is injected between the two.
When it sets up, there will be a precision match between the two surfaces
that retains the alignment achieved by the set screws. One can then remove
the setscrews and torque down the final mounting screws against this precision
surface, and all will be well.
This approach appeals to me
greatly for a few reasons. First, it's blessed by an MIT PhD, and was
used in a commercial high peformance 5-Axis CNC Grinder he collaborated
on--gotta love that! Second, it takes the art of precision machine construction
out of the realm of laser interferometers and hand scraping and moves
it closer to adjusting a 4-jaw chuck on your lathe.
Now to be sure, one does need
a precision surface to mount the linear rails to--you can't just bolt
it to any old wavy piece of metal. However, that precision is straightforward
to achieve with a surface grinding operation. Used surface grinders are
cheap, Asian import new surface grinders are cheap, and shops with grinders
one could farm the work out to are plentiful. Moreover, it is only the
shoulder and the floor surface immediately under the linear rail that
needs this treatment. It is concievable that with enough care, perhaps
one could even achieve decent results in aluminum finished with a fly
cutter and skip the surface grinding stage. It's largely a question of
the accuracy you want the machine to achieve. I would think a tenth (0.0001")
would be straightforward with surface grinding.
Let's see how this looks in
plan form:

The precision
plate (blue) sits atop the structural frame (red). Linear rail mounting
holes not shown for clarity.

A precision
ground shoulder in the precision plate locates the linear rail straight,
level, and true...
In practice, one
would use a bead of silicone cement to "o-ring" the Mogliced
gap so all the Moglice stayed in place until it hardened. Getting the
plates straight, level, and true should not be too challenging with a
tenths indicator, straightedge, and machinist's level as your tools. All
it takes is a little patience and skill with these normal tools of the
trade. No finicky scraping that requires "touch" and years of
experience to do well.
We apply a similar
principle to mount the gantry and keep it true. The gantry uprights would
have a flange at bottom accomodating the same mounting hole+set screw+Moglice
port model shown here. Work step by step, use the leveling screws to get
the gantry right where you want it, and inject the Moglice to lock that
in.
It is a tremendous
advantage that the structural framework can be built, seasoned, set up
and leveled in the place it is inteded to be used all before the precision
work really gets under way. I have on my list of researches to understand
what is needed to season such a frame. I understand there are approaches
based both on temperature and vibrational techniques. Some passage of
time would also seem to be advantageous. I wouldn't go injecting Moglice
the same day I'd finished welding up said frame, for example.
9/14/06
What's this
then?

Sketch
of a 5-Axis T&C Grinder Frame...
9/11/06
Tool Height Touchsetting/Presetting
Got interested in researching
tool height touchsetting/presetting over the weekend and collected my
notes on the new CNC Tips & Techniques
page. Since I haven't yet got a machine converted, I'm not ready to
put any of it into practice, but it was interesting reading.
Moglice and
Sliding Bearings
Ran into a query about using
Moglice to fill gaps between column and base when squaring the mill. Did
a routine web search and discovered the patent application for Moglice
is #4,329,238. Also came across a fabulous
MIT lecture notes on sliding bearings (e.g. what we call "Ways").
It had some interesting information. Sliding bearings made with Moglice,
may not require gibs, for example, because the fit is exact. Only the
master need be accurately scraped, as the secondary bearing is cast in
Moglice. This begs the question, if we have a precision straightedge of
sufficient size, can we simply cast both sides of the bearing in Moglice,
and do away with any scraping to build a precision machine tool? It would
seem so.
One serious negative with Moglice
is that it wears pretty quickly compared to cast iron. Provision must
be made to protect the ways from contaminants.
9/3/06
It's alive!
Finally got the PC for my CNC lathe project assembled

CNC
Lathe PC having Windows XP installed...
It's a full on
Athlon 64 system on a Micro-ATX motherboard. All the parts are brand new,
and you can build a system like this for about $400 if you shop carefully,
not including monitor, keyboard, or mouse.
Machine Table Covers
Clever idea: how
about taking some sheet metal and some felt to create some table covers
to make it easy to clean up when doing vise jobs?

Sheet
metal table covers make cleanup easy!
Bridgeport CNC Conversion with Single
Shot Oiling
Here is a great
shot of a lot going on underneath a Bridgeport table:

Nice single
shot oiling tubing all tied off and clamped down, "groovy" oil
passage on the freshly scraped way, and a brand new HiWin ballscrew. This
is a very
nice Bridgeport CNC conversion...
8/29/06
Ever hear
of a "Maximator"?
<Hint: Think Waterjets>
Apparently this type of liquid
pump is exactly the sort of thing needed to drive a water jet cutter.
Those beasts are way cool! If you're not familiar with them, water jets
use super high pressure (20,000 - 60,000 psi and up) streams of water
to cut with. Usually, the water carries a garnet abrasive. The results
are very precise and smoothly polished, so it is an extremely efficient
process. The fellow that runs Anvil
Bikes says he reduced his machining costs 80% when he outsourced to
a water jet shop to cut his workpieces so they required less machining
to finish. That's quite a testimony! I've read in a number of places that
rough cutting to within 0.1" can really save on the cost to machine
a part. A water jet would be the ultimate. Flow International, one of
the premier supplies of these high-dollar machines, claims their machines
will cut to within 0.003". They do so without heating the part, with
little lateral force, and with very little kerf, which is extremely helpful
in many cases.
Just one problem with all this--water
jets are expensive! They also generally take some pretty industrial support--they
don't just plug into 110V. Some folks talk about building one from time
to time, but I have yet to see anything come of it. But how about this
idea: There is a waterjet
rig built around an air powered maximator that could be attached to your
CNC mill to do water jet cutting. How about attaching one to a plasma
table to really open up some possibilities? We know the tables can be
built cheaply. Brand new, the 30HP version of this thing from WardJet,
the M-30, supposedly costs about $35K. Now we can see how to produce a
4' x 8' capacity waterjet for somewhere in the neighborhood of $50K. That's
still a huge sum of money, but it's way less than a complete new machine.
It's interesting to watch the
videos on the WardJet site. I found it particularly interesting that they
use a bed of ball bearings to hold the workpiece so that the water jet
doesn't eat up the bed too quickly. The hourly costs are also interesting--not
exactly cheap gadgets to run, but the productivity is awesome, so there
is a good return. To learn more, I did find a
really good web site that's all about water jets.
It turns out I have a lot of
things in my house that were cut with a waterjet by these guys:
Creative Cutting Service
65 Hangar Way
Watsonville, CA 95076-2476
( Monterey Bay Area )
phone: 831 728-5362 fax: 831 728-5364
email: lberk@redshift.com
Thomas Powell
has done some fantastic work on his IH Mill
His
photo site details all of it, but there are some choice pieces I particularly
covet:

One
shot oiler using Bijur manifold and orifices...

Spindle
mounted flood coolant system and enclosure...

Z-Axis
counterweight system using gas struts...

Power
Drawbar...
8/27/06
A Smithy
mill-lathe converted for linear slides

Smithy
with linear slides...
The way covers
are just rectangles of aluminum flashing with adhesive tape between each
segment...
8/07/06
CNC Dictionary
I've been busy on a number
of fronts, not the least of which has been the creation of a CNC
Dictionary to help newcomers learn the newfangled terminology
of this crazy technology as well as helping yours truly to stay organized
in my own thinking and learning process. It's been great fun putting it
together, but quite a lot of work.
Inexpensive DRO for the Mill
I've also been spending time
down in the shop, getting two axes of my inexpensive
DRO up and running:

X-Axis
DRO...
As I mention somewhere
below, the scales are quite inexpensive, and they'll be very convenient
to have in the interim before I convert to CNC. In fact, I plan to use
them for a little while post CNC conversion to help me diagnose whether
everything is working properly and to do some ballscrew error mapping
to improve the accuracy of the machine.
Converting
a Bridgeport Power Feed for the Industrial Hobbies Mill
Speaking of the
interim, I also have a project underway to convert a power feed intended
for Bridgeports for use on my IH machine. If you want one that's done
and works well (according to all reports), by all means, purchase the
model
sold by Lathemaster. At $249, it's really not a bad deal, and
after spinning the handwheels for a few projects, I've come to regard
some kind of power feed as an eventual requirement. Here is the thing
though. eBay seller "DiscountMachine" (aka Shars) will sell
you a Bridgeport compatible power feed for $169, which is quite a good
savings, and I have read some positive things about this unit over on
Practical
Machinist. I'm viewing the power feed in the same way I did the
DRO--it's an expendable project that will be useful for a time until I
convert to CNC. So, I decided to spring for one, thinking it would be
easier to sell a Bridgie-compatible unit when I was finished with it,
and that it couldn't be all that hard to adapt it to the IH Mill. Time
will tell on the former, but it does not look too hard to adapt now that
I have it in hand. I'm partway through making the shaft adapter (Bridgie
has different dimensions, of course), and that adapter coupled with a
simple plate to adapt the Bridgie bolt patter to the IH Mill and I should
be in bidness as we used to say in Texas. I'll write the whole thing up
when it's done and working.
And speaking of
the CNC conversion for the mill, I got a note from Aaron today telling
me they are shipping out my conversion kit. Yup, I broke down and ordered
one last month. Considering how slowly the lathe
conversion has gone, I thought it might speed things up a bit
if I purchased a finished kit rather than engineering one myself. The
mill is a more difficult project to get right anyway, and besides, Aaron
had the darned things on sale. I ordered the mechanicals-only kit, and
I'm thinking of using the Kelling Technology motors referred to below.
These are 600 oz in motors at a great price, Mariss F. himself has blessed
their usage in glowing terms, and I'd love to be able to compare and contrast
a stepper system (my lathe) with a full closed loop servo system on the
mill.
I
Want to Build a Pan and Box Brake
I'll keep you
posted on the mill progress, but frankly I do intend to build a few more
projects using the mill manually before I dive into the conversion. For
example, I need to build
a pan and box brake to be able to finish the chassis work for
my lathe retrofit. I love the design that appeared in "Projects in
Metal", and have the book. They come out looking great:

I'm going
to build a box brake just like this one...
I've got all the
steel for it ordered and it is sitting in my garage. Just need to finish
a few other projects (especially the mill power feed), DOH!
Centering Scope
I've mentioned
below (7/7/06) my desire to own a Centering Scope. Being a very
visual person, this just seems a great way to line things up, whether
that be a 4-jaw lathe chuck job or something in the mill. After losing
out on something like 6 scopes that all sold on eBay for over $200, I
lucked out and snagged a Heco for $115. Go figure. I don't have it in
hand yet, but I'll let you know how it works out when I get it.
Ongoing
CNC Lathe Conversion
Lastly, I wanted
to report that their continues to be some signs of glacial progress on
the lathe conversion. As the duly appointed and solitary IT support person
in our household, I was called to PC tinkering when the fan on my wife's
PC went out. Having gotten my hands dirty fooling with a PC for the first
time in a while, I thought it well if I got on with building the PC I
want to use for the lathe. I've had the parts for some time, but needed
to convert a 19" rack mount enclosure I got off eBay (what would
I do without eBay?). It turns out to be quite a lot of trouble to convert
a generic enclosure to be a PC. All sorts of little holes and openings
have to be engineered in. Lots of crazy little things have to be scrounged
up, like the little speaker to play your motherboard's beeps at startup.
At this stage, I think I've got most of it in hand, and hope to try to
assemble it soon. Once I've got a working PC, it'll be time to start on
the drive electronics enclosure. That's one of the things I need the box
brake for, to make a little bracket to hold the Geckos in an efficient
way. One thing certainly does often lead to another, doesn't it?
Odds
& Ends
How about mechanically
compensating for leadscrew error? I came across an interesting
article wherein Les Watts uses a mechanical system to correct leadscrew
error to achieve 0.0005" maximum error over 60", an improvement
of 12x over the out of box leadscrew spec. His issue was that he needed
to drive a big router gantry with a leadscrew on either side and wanted
them to match. One could be mapped in software to correct the error, but
what to do about the other? He devised a mechanism that uses a mechanical
cam to advance or retard the ballnut in order to correct errors. The really
interesting question is not considered in the article, which is, how did
he produce the cam used to correct the error? This same fellow writes
in great detail of how he produced the very flat surfaces needed for the
router using an interesting twist on scraping. Rather than use a scraper,
he knocked the high spots down with a hand grinder, and used the standard
bluing techniques to test. All in all, a very interesting and unorthodox
set of techniques.
Tool & Cutter Grinders
I've been keeping
my nose to the ground looking for ideas on a tool and cutter grinder.
It's ridiculously easy to dull a cutter, and while they're reasonably
cheap on eBay (say $10 for a nice US Made 1/2" endmill), it's even
cheaper to sharpen them. Not to mention drill bits need constant sharpening,
and custom cutters are easily made with the right grinder. I've looked
a little bit at the Deckel's and their clones that come up on eBay, but
they want an awful lot of money for one. Then there are a variety of cutter
grinders that various HSM's have made over the years.
The Quorn is probably
the most famous. It's a beautifully intricate little machine:

Quorn Cutter...
I have entertained
the idea of CNC'ing up a Quorn out of bar stock after I get my machines
converted, and I am sure it would be a fascinating project, but there
are simpler ways to get the job done.
I recently came
upon a tool grinder called the Tinker:

The
Tinker Tool and Cutter Grinder by Guy Lautard...
This
design is by the famous Guy Lautard, and he has plans and information
about it on his site. His Machinist's Bedside Reader series is excellent,
so I know that what he is offering is likely of extremely high quality
and would be worth the price of admission. I quite like the Tinker design.
It looks much simpler to build than a Quorn, and I like the idea of harnessing
it to an existing grinder rather than having to fabricate a whole new
grinding spindle for the machine. It seems to me that doing double duty
with the grinder not only saves fabrication time, but also saves space
in what will be an already over-crowded workshop for most folks.
There is also
a simpler variant called a Mini-Tinker,
and supposedly a design known as the Raymac may be even more capable than
the Tinker.
I've added this
whole topic to my Projects Wish List page.
7/28/06
Unbelievably
Cool Demo
A desktop 3D
laser scanner for $2500. Click "Product" and then "Demo".
I love that thing!
High
Speed Machining at Home
Here is another
neat idea from KDN
Tools. These guys are attaching a Proxxon IB/E tool using a spindle
clamp to get a high speed spindle for their small CNC. Here's what's cool
about this. According
to a thread on CNCZone, that spindle is powerful enough to cut
through aluminum at 20,000 rpm with a 1/8" end mill. This is also
the same high speed spindle option offered by Tormach. This would enable
the HSM (Home Shop Machinist) to try out HSM (High Speed Machining) at
very low cost. I'll give it a whirl once I get my mill CNC'd!
Servos on the Cheap!
Here's another tidbit. Mariss
F. (Mr Gecko Himself) did a test on Kelling
Technology's NEMA 34 KL34_150_90 DC Motor. Kelling is a company I've
seen recommended by John Stevenson and now Mariss, two highly respected
names in the CNC world. This is a 600 oz in servo motor for $109. Apparently
there is some pronounced cogging, but Mariss has a report on his site
about the whole test. In the end, he felt it was quite a good deal. Something
for me to keep in mind when I get ready to convert my IH
Mill. I know Aaron uses 600 oz in servo motors in his kits.
Leveling
Screws for Squaring Mill Columns
I was reading some old posts
on the IH Mill forum on CNCZone and came across some pictures of how Tormach
squares their column and mill head using set screws:

Note the
set screw between the rear and middle socket head bolts that hold the
column to the base...

Similar
set screws on the spindle head of the Tormach...
It is interesting
that the setscrews are offset diagonally on the spindle head. Presumbly
there is a similar offset on the column, but we don't have a pic of the
other side to tell. I wonder if the Tormach instructions detail how these
set screws are used to square up the machine? Now much later, I read another
post from a Tormach owner that says those are not set screws, they are
dowel pins that lock the alignment in place. Hmmm. The set screw idea
seemed so much better. I can't understand what the dowel pins are buying,
though perhaps things are scraped in so carefully that we need only align
the pins to get the mill reassembled perfectly square.
Recently, I came
across someone who had done something similar to their IH Mill:

Set screws
added to an IH Mill for squaring the column...
The author of
this mod to the IH Mill had the following to say:
I drilled and tapped
mine for 5/8 fine set screws, works great, then find a feeler gauge to
slip in next to bolt before torqueing it down and do so in stages. My
collumn is within .0005 now and i figgure on checking it again after it
gets shook in some. I got pics to show where i drilled. I have developed
some proceedure/technique to get it righ. only back off bolt so spring
washer has enough tension to hold collumn from tipping unwanted, then
do tramming, if set gets too tight then back off bolt 1/8 turn or so and
further adjust, lastly steal feeler of appropriate fit to jam into gap
under bolt and then as you apply torque to bolt check tram and readdjust
to complete. firstly tho set slides parralel to table axis as sets will
get a bite into base not allowing rotation later on. if done correctly
it'll be strong enough to take it all, and the feeler jammed under bolt
area will aid in minimizing required readjustment as torque is applied.
this is what i did. Also a not on drilling, go in steps starting with
a small drill and use a drill guide for every step all the way up to tap
drill size then use guide to start tap as well or it'll wander for sure.
7/27/06
A Row
O' Fixtures
How about the Row O' Fixtures
for getting some production going on your CNC mill:

A Row
of Collet Fixtures, by HuFlungDung...
This is from a
series of shots by HuFlung, wherein he was describing a way to let your
CNC machine assist with placing a part. In this case, the machine spindle
held a locating pin that ensured the part would be properly indexed relative
to the hole the pin was in and the collet. I added this pic for a couple
of reasons. First, a fellow over on CNCZone was commenting on how the
large table on IH mills might make possible multiple vises so you could
tee up a whole lot of work. This represents that example with collets
for holding round parts. Second, I had a thought. Since the part is round,
the spin indexer doesn't need to be positioned radially with any accuracy,
the bottom just needs to be flat with no chips between it and the table
(assuming the index and table are properly made, of course!). That's a
very cool thing when you think about the amount of trouble needed to tram
in a vise or rotary table. I just can't help but think that if you can
arrange for the part to just drop into a collet, you can machine the rest
of it and the whole setup would be quick. Even if the part is not round,
if it has a round boss to fit the collet, you could drop the rough stock
in with a boss, and let the mill work out the rest of it under CNC. The
boss could even be potentially milled off at the end.
7/21/06
A big box
arrived in the mail--eBay again
It contained the scales I plan
to use to make a cheezy DRO for my IH Mill.
It'll be a little while before I'm ready to convert the mill to CNC (heck,
it's taking forever to get done converting the lathe), so I thought it
would be nice to have a simple DRO capability. I bought 3 scales on eBay
for about $200. I'll need to fabricate the brackets, but heck, what else
is a machine shop for? I'm about halfway through the z-axis quill DRO
as we speak.
A Quick Checkup
on the Health of a Milling Machine
I found this description somewhere
for how to do a quick checkup on the health of a mill:
Listen for excess
spindle bearing noise or clatter, throughout the speed range.
Put a dial indicator on the
inside of the spindle taper, rotate slowly by hand and look for run
out. You would like to see less than 0.001", anywhere close to
that or over means the spindle is either bent from a crash or worn or
has worn bearings. If its not too bad (0.001" to 0.003" or
so) it can be reground, but figure $300 to $500 plus some hassle for
that.
Put a dial indicator on the
table indicating against the side of the quill and in the middle of
travel of the table (the most worn position) issue commands to move
the table back and forth back to the same position. Do this for X,Y
and Z. The difference shown on the indicator when moving from opposite
directions will show you how much backlash each axis has. When this
machine was new it probably had less than 0.001" backlash, it would
be nice to see no more than 0.0015" or so at this point.
How much you can stand depends
on how precise your planned work needs to be. My machine is at around
0.0015" on all axises and that's ok for what I do.
I'll have to try that on my
IH Mill one of these days and see what the measurements are. Speaking
of IH, Aaron has finally gotten
his web site sorted out and all the old helpful how-tos are back up
there along with some significant new how-tos on how to use the mills
for production work. It's all very good information, worth a look see.
One thing I noticed that I hadn't read before was a section on squaring
the mill. I just got done spending quite a lot of time tramming the mill
and here's another procedure that ought to be contemplated. It involves
shimming the column base to make sure the z-axis is properly square. Good
information!
Spring-Loaded
Parallels Separator
How about this cool gizmo,
a Kurt spring-loaded parallels separator:

Kurt spring-loaded
parallels separators...
There is always
some crazy little gizmo I haven't gotten around to buying yet! I think
this particular gizmo is actually made by SPI, as Penn has it in their
catalog for $39.95. It seems like the sort of thing that wouldn't be very
hard to make.
7/18/06
Rotary Table Fun
I had a little fun with my
new Phase II 8" Rotary Table today:

Fan cutout
done with rotary table on the mill...
I just did it
by eyeball and one end hung up on the handwheel so I couldn't do things
as symmetrical as I would have liked, but all in all it turned out tolerably
well. I think I'm going to like that table a whole lot too! At this stage
I think I am within spitting distance of being ready to assemble the PC
enclosure. Just a few more holes to drill, but hopefully I can get the
PC up and running this weekend. That would be a satisfying step forward
on the project.
Extremely
Small CNC Machines
From the department
of "I have no idea why, but they sure are cool," I offer a series
of extremely small CNC machines:

Really
slick looking design. Made of MDF, 80/20 extrusions, and UHMW plastic
pads so things slide. The spindle is an air powered pencil die grinder.

A closer
view of the table. You can see the UHMW pads. Motors are NEMA 17--tiny!

Extremely
tiny--not sure what it could even be used for. Uses stepper motors salvaged
from printers and a Dremel cable drive spindle...

The Fidgiting
Widgitmaster's version is imaculate as always. He sure likes those T-slots!
7/17/06
CNC Lathe Conversion Status
By now, you must be wondering
if I ever work on my CNC Lathe Conversion,
as progress reports have been few and far between. Let me give a quick
status recap, because there has been some work, albeit slow. My current
task is to complete the two rack mount enclosures and build a rack to
put them in. One enclosure will contain the PC, while the other will contain
the DC Power Supply, Geckos, and GRex,
along with miscellaneous relays and other goodies. I started with
the PC enclosure, and I am just about done. There are a heck of a lot
of holes to be drilled and small hardware to be located before you can
turn a generic enclosure into a PC enclosure! You have to arrange for
a power on momentary contact front panel switch, motherboard mounting
on insulated stand offs, power supply mounting, hard disk mounting, DVD
mounting, cooling fan mounting, and appropriate cutouts for all of this.
I'm sure I've missed something, but I'll keep drilling holes until I've
got a place for all the components and then I will connect them all up
and try to bring the PC up. Once it is running Windows XP happily, I will
move on to building the second enclosure, followed by the rack that will
hold both enclosures, a keyboard tray, and a stalk for my ELO touch panel
screen. Whew!
Along the way I have also managed
to order a variety of components that will be needed, including:
- Shielded
cable from Action Electronics for the Step Motor (and potentially encoder)
wiring. I went ahead and bought a full spool as I may want to use
it on a variety of projects over time.
- Connectors. I decided on
6-pin microphone
connectors, also from Action Electronics.
- A lot of other miscellaneous
odds and ends like a SPST switch with safety cover (see below) that will
be used to control power to the driver electronics enclosure.
I am hoping that with the enclosures
made, progress can pick up. Since the work of building these enclosures
is relatively boring, I keep taking breaks to go do "real" machining,
such as the vise stop I recently made.
Odds &
Ends
7204CTDULP4
Universal Duplex pair of 15 degree angular contact bearings suitable for
mounting ballscrews or perhaps spindles. These are ABEC-7's for $199.95
from the reliable firm of Nachi. Not bad! Got the tip from a guy on HSM.
If I could find a set with a larger angle and designed for heavy preload
(these are for "light"), they would be even better, but these
are pretty nice for the price. If you don't want to spring for the ABEC-7's,
you can get some really
cheap "B" angle 7204's for only $23.88 in ABEC-3. These
latter are probably also not too bad for the HSM project.
Z-Axis for
a Router
How about this for a nice little
Z-axis for the router crowd:

Interesting
slide design, the round rails are embedded in the aluminum and held with
bolts...

Uses a RotoZip
router...

This fellow (eBay
seller yukonjasper) is selling these on eBay for $175 buy it now, without
the Roto-Zip or stepper motor. Seems like a pretty nice deal.
Yuasa R8 Quick Change System
I came across
this nifty set of Yuasa Quick Change toolholders for R8 machines (like
Bridgeports and my Industrial Hobbies mill):

The Yuasa
Quick Change Set...

Quick
Change R8 Chuck...

A set
of the holders...

Aren't
they Kewl?
I'm not sure how
the holders get locked into the chuck, but they sure are cool. The seller
didn't know much about them, but thought they might have the brand name
"Kwik Switch". This set sold for about $320, and I kick myself
for not stepping up to take them. Oh well. I did purchase plans to make
a powered drawbar for my mill from a butterfly impact wrench. That would
also speed tool changes up considerably.
Tip
of the Day: If you are getting long stringy chips, crank up the speed.
7/16/06
A New Asian CNC Mini-Lathe
I love the travelling chip
guard on this CNC Mini Lathe:

Nice travelling
chip guard!
I'm thinking of
making something similar for my lathe at some point. I think what I will
do is get some sheet Lexan and bend it over a cylindrical form using a
heat gun to soften it up. I might even make one up the full travel of
my lathe so I don't have to fool around making a rail system so it moves.
JerryFlyGuy's
Flat Rail Installation for a Gantry Machine
Many moons ago
(4/9/2006, to be precise), a fellow named "JerryFlyGuy" set
out to determine how best to install a set of linear ways in as true,
flat, and square a fashion as possible. Many possibilities for it were
discussed in quite a long thread over at the CNCZone. At last JerryFlyGuy
settled on an approach, and a very interesting one it is too. He is using
a very fine wire as a continuity test to tell when the rail is straight
and a little jig (laser cut) that fits over the square tubing with screws
that let him tweak the rail left or right:

Straightening
jig used to position the linear rail onto the square tubing...

Pliers
are holding the continuity test wire while the allen head is used to tweak
the rail left or right. Once it is in the correct position, Jerry then
drills a mounting hole. He has started off with drill bushings to create
pilot holes.
I believe once
Jerry gets all of the holes drilled his next step will be to pour a Turcite
like substance between "dams" to provide a flat surface to mount
the linear ways on. More news as it develops.
Precision
Fly Cutter
Here is a slightly
different kind of flycutter that came up on eBay the other day as a "Precision
Fly Cutter":



I don't know how
"precision" they are, but they're interesting. Note how they're
designed to fit a shell mill arbor. They also have multiple positions
to hold a cutter. Looks like the holes were drilled round and then broached
for square lathe-style turning tools to be used as cutters. Looks like
the are secured by 2 set screws. But why run multiple holes? Do people
run more than one cutter on a fly cutter? I'll have to ask on one of the
boards.
7/9/06
Motor Electronics Safety Switch
: I want to put a safety switch
on my CNC Lathe motor electronics. I plan to wait on firing them up until
the PC is booted and Mach 3 is up. I suspect it can also serve as an addition
E-Stop. I'll wire the incoming power to everything in the box through
this switch:

Safety
Switch for Motor Electronics Enclosure...
Action Electronics
sells them too if you search on "Safety Switch".
7/8/06
Roh'lix?
An interesting alternative
to the ballscrew for CNC applications is called the "Roh'lix".
They have virtually no backlash, and are much less susceptible to contamination
than ballscrews. They have the ability to slip if overloaded, and I suspect
this potential limits their thrust and may make them susceptible to losing
steps in open loop systems. The Roh'lix runs on just a steel shaft, which
are certainly available pretty cheaply. May be worth a look for certain
applications. Given their low thrust capability, they are said to be excellent
for CMM machines. I wonder how well they would work for a plasma table?
They are also available with a quick disconnect option which would make
manual positioning possible. The Roh'lix patent is 4947698. I wonder how
hard it is to make them?
A similar idea is the "rolling
ring" drive, which definitely looks buildable.
Making Connecting Rods for a Model Engine
I thought this was a very cool
picture that explains a clever way to make connecting rods for the Model
Engineer:

First
turn them on the lathe, then finish with a mill. Note how the split portion
already existed on the turned pistons. These are for a scale model of
the DeHavilland
Cirrus aircraft engine...
Pot Chucks for 5C Collet Systems
While on the subject
of clever machining tricks, here is a nifty picture showing the many uses
of a "Pot Chuck" for offset work:

No idea
what those parts are, but they are sure cool, eh? Someone suggested in
an email to me that they are fine adjustments for a Norris-style
wood plane...
A pot chuck is
a 5C collet that can be modified to make a custom collet for your work.
This fellow has made one that takes the little offset slugs to machine
the brass. You can see he has quite a little variety for whatever it is
he is producing on his mini production line. Note that each little slug
lines up a different portion on the center line for easy access in the
lathe. From left to right there is the little nib that sticks out, then
the little set screw that clamps the thing to the thread (a backlash adjustment,
perhaps?). Moving along we see three collet systems, one to machine the
threaded portion, one to turn the ball, and the last one to allow the
ball to be bored.
7/7/06
I Want a Centering Scope!
I really want a centering
scope--I just think it would make it so much easier to line up precisely
in the mill or even to use a 4-jaw chuck. They are expensive. I have missed
out on them on eBay probably 6 or 8 times by just not being willing to
bid enough. They usually go for about $120 or more. It occurs to me that
it's a bit silly this function is not handled by a webcam-like approach,
and then I got to looking at the Intel digital microscopes (QX3 and QX5).
Well it seems there is a great piece of shareware called miXscope
that really enhances these beauties and this just might be the ticket
to use one as a centering scope. There's just the issue of mounting it
accurately to make it work as such. I may look into this, or I may just
deal with what a real scope costs.

Centering
Scope Used to Precisely Position On Center of Part...
7/03/06
"Printing" 3D Objects in Steel
Just came across one of the
coolest things I have seen in a long time. How about the ability to "print"
3D objects in steel:

Some
3D printed art by artist Bathsheba Grossman...
It's almost like
the materializers in Star Trek! Artist Grossman starts from a Rhino 3D
model and the machine can directly reproduce that model from metal powder
in steel or bronze. Apparently its a laser lithography technique where
the laser interacts with fine metal powder that is coated with a laser-sensitive
binder. That binder solidifies the object layer by layer. Once it has
been fully solidified, the object is placed in an oven that has just the
right temperature to weld the metal into finished product with reducing
it to a melted puddle. Very cool!
Bathesda also
provides a fascinating sculpture called "Little Star" that she's
put into the public domain so others can build them:

Little
Star...
Little star is
intended to be plasma cut from metal and then assembled with silver solder
or welds. The plans she provides are for a 14" tall model, but I
would love to make one much larger. Will have to look at what my plasma
table is capable of when I get it built.
Cross Drilling Jig
Came across the
idea of a cross drilling jig over on Practical Machinist:

Cross
drilling jig...
These are handy
when cross drilling shafts. You'll note it is build around a captive V-Block,
and there is a gizmo to hold a drill bushing at the top that is on a couple
of sliding rods. This one is store bought, but it seems like an ideal
quick project for a machinist to build one.
Earlier Entries in
the Blog...
|